{
 "_generated_by": "AI-generated with Claude Code (Anthropic), directed and reviewed by the Moonat team.",
 "_note": "Place-pane photo gallery (contract C24 site-gallery). Built by scripts/gallery/build_gallery.py from the skyline comparisons (docs/validation/photo_batch/, docs/validation/real_photos.json) and NASA scans. Photos: NASA, public domain. Quotes: verbatim from the Apollo Lunar Surface Journal. Posts: public posts, quoted exactly as posted (StarHab's keeps its closing emoji, the one exception to Moonat's no-emoji rule, as its record says). No ratings, scores or like counts.",
 "schema": "moonat-gallery/1",
 "disclaimer": "Historic NASA photos and quotes; not an endorsement of Moonat.",
 "camera_models": {
  "hasselblad_61": {
   "name": "Hasselblad EL Data Camera, Zeiss Biogon f/5.6 60 mm",
   "focal_mm": 61.1,
   "frame_mm": 53.0,
   "hfov_deg": 46.894,
   "note": "pinhole; focal length 61.1 mm from the Zeiss data sheet; the web copy is the 53 x 53 mm film frame centred on the central reseau cross (the principal point)"
  },
  "surveyor_tv": {
   "name": "Surveyor television camera (vidicon), wide-angle mode",
   "note": "the printed picture is cropped around the Earth; field of view from the Earth's angular radius"
  }
 },
 "recreation": {
  "renderer": "web/js/sky (contract C8), live in the browser",
  "skyline": "the photo's horizon profile (the one its skyline fit used: SLDEM2015 59 m, LDEM_64, LDEM_16; eye 1.5 m; or the catalog site's C3 for the round 1 fits and Surveyor 3), drawn exactly by the sky view",
  "terrain": "one terrain per photo (C24 terrain): the catalog site's SLDEM2015 C4 patch and far rings moved to the camera place (web/js/app/gallery_terrain.js), the same DEMs as the skyline; NASA Moon Trek only when they cannot be loaded",
  "decoration": "none: no procedural rocks or micro relief in a photo recreation (they never match the real ones)",
  "sky": "physics skyState (contract C6) at taken_utc",
  "label": "Moonat recreation: computed Sun and Earth, not a photograph. Moonat draws the terrain from NASA elevation data (SLDEM2015, 59 m cells); small craters and rocks are not modelled."
 },
 "totals": {
  "photos": 34,
  "quotes": 13,
  "image_bytes": 10746074,
  "thumb_bytes": 800324,
  "posts": 1
 },
 "sites": {
  "apollo11": {
   "name": "Apollo 11 (Tranquility Base)",
   "mission": "Apollo 11",
   "photos": [
    {
     "id": "AS11-40-5875",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo11/AS11-40-5875.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo11/AS11-40-5875_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 448077,
     "film": "colour",
     "title": "Buzz Aldrin and the flag",
     "caption": "Aldrin beside the US flag; the LM on the left, footprints in the foreground.",
     "uploader": "N. Armstrong",
     "uploader_full": "Neil A. Armstrong",
     "role": "CDR",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Buzz and the U.S. flag'; NASA caption: 'Neil A. Armstrong, commander, took this picture'.",
     "mission": "Apollo 11",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1969-07-21T03:42:33Z",
     "time_source": "ALSJ image library, mission clock 110:10:33",
     "get": "110:10:33",
     "get_utc": "1969-07-21T03:42:33Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": 0.6741,
      "lon_deg": 23.473,
      "acc_m": 30,
      "source": "catalog site apollo11 (the LM; the fit used the catalog horizon)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a11/images11.html#5875",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 11 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://images.nasa.gov/details/as11-40-5875",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 145.16,
      "pitch_deg": -5.087,
      "roll_deg": -2.113,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 2.0,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "../horizons/apollo11.json",
      "format": "C3 JSON (catalog site)",
      "observer_height_m": 2.0
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.04,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.02,
      "n_points": 351,
      "n_outliers": 0,
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "flat mare: the heading is not fixed by the skyline"
      ],
      "record": "docs/validation/real_photos.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo11",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       0.0,
       0.0
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.0,
      "near_share": 1.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     },
     "limit": {
      "kind": "near_horizon",
      "near_share": 1.0,
      "short": "Recreation limited: near horizon < 1 km",
      "text": "Recreation limited: across the whole frame the skyline is nearer than 1 km, where the elevation data (59 m cells) cannot draw the real crater rims and rises. The far skyline is exact; the near one is not."
     }
    }
   ],
   "quotes": [
    {
     "id": "q-apollo11-0",
     "kind": "quote",
     "person": "N. Armstrong",
     "person_full": "Neil A. Armstrong",
     "role": "CDR",
     "mission": "Apollo 11",
     "text": "Houston, Tranquility Base here. The Eagle has landed.",
     "get": "102:45:58",
     "utc": "1969-07-20T20:17:58Z",
     "context": "Just after the landing",
     "tag": "Historic quote",
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a11/a11.landing.html",
     "source_label": "Apollo 11 Lunar Surface Journal: The First Lunar Landing",
     "verified": "2026-11-17, word for word against the ALSJ transcript"
    },
    {
     "id": "q-apollo11-1",
     "kind": "quote",
     "person": "N. Armstrong",
     "person_full": "Neil A. Armstrong",
     "role": "CDR",
     "mission": "Apollo 11",
     "text": "That's one small step for (a) man; one giant leap for mankind.",
     "get": "109:24:23",
     "utc": "1969-07-21T02:56:23Z",
     "context": "The first step onto the Moon",
     "tag": "Historic quote",
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a11/a11.step.html",
     "source_label": "Apollo 11 Lunar Surface Journal: One Small Step",
     "verified": "2026-11-17, word for word against the ALSJ transcript",
     "note": "The ALSJ notes that the 'a' is not audible in the recordings."
    },
    {
     "id": "q-apollo11-2",
     "kind": "quote",
     "person": "E. Aldrin",
     "person_full": "Edwin E. Aldrin Jr.",
     "role": "LMP",
     "mission": "Apollo 11",
     "text": "Magnificent desolation.",
     "get": "109:43:24",
     "utc": "1969-07-21T03:15:24Z",
     "context": "Stepping off the ladder",
     "tag": "Historic quote",
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a11/a11.step.html",
     "source_label": "Apollo 11 Lunar Surface Journal: One Small Step",
     "verified": "2026-11-17, word for word against the ALSJ transcript"
    }
   ]
  },
  "apollo12": {
   "name": "Apollo 12 (Ocean of Storms)",
   "mission": "Apollo 12",
   "photos": [
    {
     "id": "AS12-46-6752",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo12/AS12-46-6752.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo12/AS12-46-6752_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 378072,
     "film": "colour",
     "title": "The flag and Conrad's shadow",
     "caption": "Down-Sun from the LM at the start of EVA-1, the US flag beside Pete Conrad's shadow.",
     "uploader": "C. Conrad",
     "uploader_full": "Charles Conrad Jr.",
     "role": "CDR",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: magazine 46 'used by Pete Conrad during EVA-1'; 'Down-Sun with the U.S. flag just to the right of Pete's shadow'.",
     "mission": "Apollo 12",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1969-11-19T12:46:30Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "116:24:47",
     "get_utc": "1969-11-19T12:46:47Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": -3.012638,
      "lon_deg": -23.421683,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC Temporal Traverse: photographer's LROC-located track at the frame times (median)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a12/images12.html#6752",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 12 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://www.lpi.usra.edu/resources/apollo/images/print/AS12/46/6752.jpg",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 202.034,
      "pitch_deg": -5.982,
      "roll_deg": -1.49,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo12/AS12-46-6752.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -1424.3,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0651,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0352,
      "n_points": 879,
      "n_outliers": 33,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 1.3,
       "min": 0.89,
       "max": 25.34
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "heading weakly fixed (another heading fits almost as well)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "CDR",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS12-46-6752.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo12",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       -2.5,
       -7.2
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.64,
      "near_share": 0.05,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS12-47-6918",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo12/AS12-47-6918.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo12/AS12-47-6918_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 401886,
     "film": "colour",
     "title": "Seismometer and Central Station",
     "caption": "The ALSEP's seismometer, with the Central Station behind it.",
     "uploader": "A. Bean",
     "uploader_full": "Alan L. Bean",
     "role": "LMP",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Al has backed up to take a longer distance down-Sun of the PSE'; Pete's shadow is at the left edge.",
     "mission": "Apollo 12",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1969-11-19T13:54:44Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "117:30:24",
     "get_utc": "1969-11-19T13:52:24Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": -3.009914,
      "lon_deg": -23.424673,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC track"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a12/images12.html#6918",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 12 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://www.lpi.usra.edu/resources/apollo/images/print/AS12/47/6918.jpg",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 137.77,
      "pitch_deg": -7.276,
      "roll_deg": -3.601,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo12/AS12-47-6918.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -1421.5,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0724,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0503,
      "n_points": 955,
      "n_outliers": 0,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 3.61,
       "min": 1.12,
       "max": 13.56
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "heading weakly fixed (another heading fits almost as well)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "LMP",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS12-47-6918.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo12",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       -93.0,
       75.3
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.17,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS12-46-6826",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo12/AS12-46-6826.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo12/AS12-46-6826_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 512580,
     "film": "colour",
     "title": "Bean at the ALSEP",
     "caption": "Alan Bean at the seismometer; the glow around him is a dust smudge on the lens.",
     "uploader": "C. Conrad",
     "uploader_full": "Charles Conrad Jr.",
     "role": "CDR",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Pete has turned toward the Central Station ... Al seems to be adjusting the PSE thermal skirt'.",
     "mission": "Apollo 12",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1969-11-19T14:25:00Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "118:00:46",
     "get_utc": "1969-11-19T14:22:46Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": -3.010374,
      "lon_deg": -23.425382,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC Temporal Traverse: photographer's LROC-located track at the frame times (median)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a12/images12.html#6826",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 12 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://www.lpi.usra.edu/resources/apollo/images/print/AS12/46/6826.jpg",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 345.01,
      "pitch_deg": -1.098,
      "roll_deg": -5.465,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo12/AS12-46-6826.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -1420.67,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0351,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0241,
      "n_points": 497,
      "n_outliers": 162,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 1.84,
       "min": 0.06,
       "max": 6.22
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "broken photo skyline (7 jumps: unlit or low-contrast slope)",
       "heading weakly fixed (another heading fits almost as well)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "CDR",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS12-46-6826.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo12",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       -114.4,
       61.4
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.12,
      "near_share": 0.41,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     },
     "limit": {
      "kind": "near_horizon",
      "near_share": 0.41,
      "short": "Recreation limited: near horizon < 1 km",
      "text": "Recreation limited: over 41 % of this frame the skyline is nearer than 1 km, where the elevation data (59 m cells) cannot draw the real crater rims and rises. The far skyline is exact; the near one is not."
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS12-46-6827",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo12/AS12-46-6827.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo12/AS12-46-6827_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 642662,
     "film": "colour",
     "title": "A mound south of the ALSEP",
     "caption": "A large mound, with Head Crater in the background.",
     "uploader": "C. Conrad",
     "uploader_full": "Charles Conrad Jr.",
     "role": "CDR",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Pete takes a view to the south of the large mound with Head Crater in the background'.",
     "mission": "Apollo 12",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1969-11-19T14:28:30Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "118:06:36",
     "get_utc": "1969-11-19T14:28:36Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": -3.010374,
      "lon_deg": -23.425382,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC Temporal Traverse: photographer's LROC-located track at the frame times (median)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a12/images12.html#6827",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 12 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://www.lpi.usra.edu/resources/apollo/images/print/AS12/46/6827.jpg",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 257.93,
      "pitch_deg": -5.006,
      "roll_deg": -5.408,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo12/AS12-46-6827.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -1420.67,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0484,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.026,
      "n_points": 842,
      "n_outliers": 5,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 5.04,
       "min": 0.06,
       "max": 24.28
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "broken photo skyline (10 jumps: unlit or low-contrast slope)",
       "heading weakly fixed (another heading fits almost as well)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "CDR",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS12-46-6827.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo12",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       -114.4,
       61.4
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.12,
      "near_share": 0.13,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS12-48-7134",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo12/AS12-48-7134.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo12/AS12-48-7134_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 427782,
     "film": "black and white",
     "title": "Conrad at Surveyor 3",
     "caption": "Pete Conrad shakes Surveyor 3, which had landed 31 months before, to see if it is firmly planted.",
     "uploader": "A. Bean",
     "uploader_full": "Alan L. Bean",
     "role": "LMP",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: magazine 48 'used by Al Bean during EVA-2'; 'Pete is jiggling the spacecraft' (Pete is in the frame).",
     "mission": "Apollo 12",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1969-11-20T06:39:00Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "134:16:54",
     "get_utc": "1969-11-20T06:38:54Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": -3.016272,
      "lon_deg": -23.417948,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC Temporal Traverse: photographer's LROC-located track at the frame times (median)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a12/images12.html#7134",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 12 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://www.lpi.usra.edu/resources/apollo/images/print/AS12/48/7134.jpg",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 228.27,
      "pitch_deg": -9.005,
      "roll_deg": -4.439,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo12/AS12-48-7134.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -1425.0,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0755,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0451,
      "n_points": 706,
      "n_outliers": 83,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 2.13,
       "min": 0.72,
       "max": 25.57
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "heading weakly fixed (another heading fits almost as well)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "LMP",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS12-48-7134.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo12",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       110.5,
       -117.3
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.7,
      "near_share": 0.19,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS12-48-7148",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo12/AS12-48-7148.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo12/AS12-48-7148_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 492892,
     "film": "black and white",
     "title": "Block Crater",
     "caption": "Cross-Sun 'before' picture of the Block Crater sample area, with Pete Conrad.",
     "uploader": "A. Bean",
     "uploader_full": "Alan L. Bean",
     "role": "LMP",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Cross-sun before of the Block Crater sample area. Al is a little too far away for ideal focus.'",
     "mission": "Apollo 12",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1969-11-20T07:03:19Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "134:41:22",
     "get_utc": "1969-11-20T07:03:22Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": -3.01328,
      "lon_deg": -23.417941,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC Temporal Traverse: photographer's LROC-located track at the frame times (median)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a12/images12.html#7148",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 12 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://www.lpi.usra.edu/resources/apollo/images/print/AS12/48/7148.jpg",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 205.06,
      "pitch_deg": -17.927,
      "roll_deg": -4.018,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo12/AS12-48-7148.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -1421.35,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0657,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0415,
      "n_points": 570,
      "n_outliers": 33,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 2.07,
       "min": 1.01,
       "max": 25.64
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "heading weakly fixed (another heading fits almost as well)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "LMP",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS12-48-7148.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo12",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       110.7,
       -26.7
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.39,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    }
   ],
   "quotes": [
    {
     "id": "q-apollo12-3",
     "kind": "quote",
     "person": "C. Conrad",
     "person_full": "Charles Conrad Jr.",
     "role": "CDR",
     "mission": "Apollo 12",
     "text": "Whoopie! Man, that may have been a small one for Neil, but that's a long one for me.",
     "get": "115:22:16",
     "utc": "1969-11-19T11:44:16Z",
     "context": "Jumping down from the footpad",
     "tag": "Historic quote",
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a12/a12.eva1prelim.html",
     "source_label": "Apollo 12 Lunar Surface Journal: \"That may have been a small one for Neil...\"",
     "verified": "2026-11-17, word for word against the ALSJ transcript"
    },
    {
     "id": "q-apollo12-4",
     "kind": "quote",
     "person": "A. Bean",
     "person_full": "Alan L. Bean",
     "role": "LMP",
     "mission": "Apollo 12",
     "text": "Boy, the LM looks nice on the outside.",
     "get": "115:51:27",
     "utc": "1969-11-19T12:13:27Z",
     "context": "Climbing down the ladder",
     "tag": "Historic quote",
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a12/a12.eva1prelim.html",
     "source_label": "Apollo 12 Lunar Surface Journal: \"That may have been a small one for Neil...\"",
     "verified": "2026-11-17, word for word against the ALSJ transcript"
    }
   ]
  },
  "apollo14": {
   "name": "Apollo 14 (Fra Mauro)",
   "mission": "Apollo 14",
   "photos": [
    {
     "id": "AS14-67-9374",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo14/AS14-67-9374.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo14/AS14-67-9374_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 390358,
     "film": "colour",
     "title": "Mitchell on the geophone line",
     "caption": "Ed Mitchell walks back along the geophone line, firing the thumper every 15 feet.",
     "uploader": "A. Shepard",
     "uploader_full": "Alan B. Shepard Jr.",
     "role": "CDR",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Al took this shot from near the MET, looking southeast along the geophone line toward Ed'.",
     "mission": "Apollo 14",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1971-02-05T18:24:39Z",
     "time_source": "ALSJ frame time (median of the set)",
     "get": "117:24:33",
     "get_utc": "1971-02-05T18:27:35Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": -3.644429,
      "lon_deg": -17.477222,
      "acc_m": 50.0,
      "source": "ALSJ frame time + CDR's LROC track"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a14/images14.html#9374",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 14 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://eol.jsc.nasa.gov/DatabaseImages/ISD/highres/AS14/AS14-67-9374.JPG",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 173.832,
      "pitch_deg": -6.89,
      "roll_deg": -0.4,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo14/AS14-67-9374.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -1062.36,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.047,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0173,
      "n_points": 834,
      "n_outliers": 165,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 2.72,
       "min": 2.31,
       "max": 4.09
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "broken photo skyline (15 jumps: unlit or low-contrast slope)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "CDR",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS14-67-9374.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo14",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       -176.1,
       26.4
      ],
      "ground_check_m": 0.14,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS14-68-9405",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo14/AS14-68-9405.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo14/AS14-68-9405_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 302026,
     "film": "black and white",
     "title": "Shepard at Station A",
     "caption": "Al Shepard with the core tube and its extension handle, part of Mitchell's Station A pan.",
     "uploader": "E. Mitchell",
     "uploader_full": "Edgar D. Mitchell",
     "role": "LMP",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: magazine 68 'used by Ed Mitchell during EVA-2'; 'Superb picture of Al with the core tube'.",
     "mission": "Apollo 14",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1971-02-06T09:19:42Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "132:16:44",
     "get_utc": "1971-02-06T09:19:46Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": -3.64285,
      "lon_deg": -17.466932,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC Temporal Traverse: photographer's LROC-located track at the frame times (median)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a14/images14.html#9405",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 14 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://www.lpi.usra.edu/resources/apollo/images/print/AS14/68/9405.jpg",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 265.41,
      "pitch_deg": -0.149,
      "roll_deg": -3.442,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo14/AS14-68-9405.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -1063.15,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0421,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0194,
      "n_points": 528,
      "n_outliers": 173,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 2.01,
       "min": 0.53,
       "max": 2.67
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "broken photo skyline (6 jumps: unlit or low-contrast slope)",
       "heading weakly fixed (another heading fits almost as well)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "LMP",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS14-68-9405.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo14",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       135.1,
       74.2
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.14,
      "near_share": 0.45,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     },
     "limit": {
      "kind": "near_horizon",
      "near_share": 0.45,
      "short": "Recreation limited: near horizon < 1 km",
      "text": "Recreation limited: over 45 % of this frame the skyline is nearer than 1 km, where the elevation data (59 m cells) cannot draw the real crater rims and rises. The far skyline is exact; the near one is not."
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS14-64-9094",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo14/AS14-64-9094.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo14/AS14-64-9094_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 211575,
     "film": "black and white",
     "title": "The handcart",
     "caption": "Across the top of the Modular Equipment Transporter, the two-wheeled cart of Apollo 14.",
     "uploader": "A. Shepard",
     "uploader_full": "Alan B. Shepard Jr.",
     "role": "CDR",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Magazine 64 was used by Al Shepard during EVA-2'; 'across the top of the MET'.",
     "mission": "Apollo 14",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1971-02-06T09:52:17Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": null,
     "get_utc": null,
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": -3.64081,
      "lon_deg": -17.451131,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC Temporal Traverse: photographer's LROC-located track at the frame times (median)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a14/images14.html#9094",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 14 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://www.lpi.usra.edu/resources/apollo/images/print/AS14/64/9094.jpg",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 228.46,
      "pitch_deg": 1.053,
      "roll_deg": -0.236,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo14/AS14-64-9094.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -1042.6,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0272,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0166,
      "n_points": 951,
      "n_outliers": 0,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 2.84,
       "min": 2.55,
       "max": 3.67
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "heading weakly fixed (another heading fits almost as well)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "CDR",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS14-64-9094.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo14",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       613.0,
       136.1
      ],
      "ground_check_m": 0.0,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS14-64-9104",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo14/AS14-64-9104.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo14/AS14-64-9104_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 361954,
     "film": "black and white",
     "title": "Toward Cone Crater's rim",
     "caption": "A frame of Shepard's pan on the way up to Cone Crater, boulders in the foreground.",
     "uploader": "A. Shepard",
     "uploader_full": "Alan B. Shepard Jr.",
     "role": "CDR",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Magazine 64 was used by Al Shepard during EVA-2'; frame of his pan ('Rightward of 9103').",
     "mission": "Apollo 14",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1971-02-06T10:27:08Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": null,
     "get_utc": null,
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": -3.631944,
      "lon_deg": -17.428094,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC Temporal Traverse: photographer's LROC-located track at the frame times (median)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a14/images14.html#9104",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 14 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://www.lpi.usra.edu/resources/apollo/images/print/AS14/64/9104.jpg",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 355.29,
      "pitch_deg": -3.059,
      "roll_deg": -1.399,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo14/AS14-64-9104.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -957.78,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0116,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.007,
      "n_points": 956,
      "n_outliers": 0,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 10.42,
       "min": 8.88,
       "max": 15.75
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "heading weakly fixed (another heading fits almost as well)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "CDR",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS14-64-9104.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo14",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       1309.8,
       404.7
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.2,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS14-68-9475",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo14/AS14-68-9475.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo14/AS14-68-9475_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 349378,
     "film": "black and white",
     "title": "Turtle Rock",
     "caption": "Turtle Rock, a boulder Mitchell photographed near the end of EVA-2.",
     "uploader": "E. Mitchell",
     "uploader_full": "Edgar D. Mitchell",
     "role": "LMP",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Ed has stepped to his left to repeat 9472 ... This is an excellent picture of Turtle Rock.'",
     "mission": "Apollo 14",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1971-02-06T12:02:14Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": null,
     "get_utc": null,
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": -3.643501,
      "lon_deg": -17.473346,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC track"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a14/images14.html#9475",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 14 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://www.lpi.usra.edu/resources/apollo/images/print/AS14/68/9475.jpg",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 252.71,
      "pitch_deg": -10.942,
      "roll_deg": -2.41,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo14/AS14-68-9475.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -1061.54,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0699,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0306,
      "n_points": 804,
      "n_outliers": 26,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 2.13,
       "min": 0.3,
       "max": 2.72
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "heading weakly fixed (another heading fits almost as well)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "LMP",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS14-68-9475.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo14",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       -58.9,
       54.5
      ],
      "ground_check_m": 0.01,
      "near_share": 0.18,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS14-64-9200",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo14/AS14-64-9200.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo14/AS14-64-9200_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 134771,
     "film": "black and white",
     "title": "The solar wind collector",
     "caption": "The Solar Wind Collector, a foil sail that caught particles from the Sun.",
     "uploader": "A. Shepard",
     "uploader_full": "Alan B. Shepard Jr.",
     "role": "CDR",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Magazine 64 was used by Al Shepard during EVA-2'; 'showing the top of the SWC'.",
     "mission": "Apollo 14",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1971-02-06T12:08:42Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": null,
     "get_utc": null,
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": -3.645916,
      "lon_deg": -17.472043,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC Temporal Traverse: photographer's LROC-located track at the frame times (median)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a14/images14.html#9200",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 14 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://www.lpi.usra.edu/resources/apollo/images/print/AS14/64/9200.jpg",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 9.368,
      "pitch_deg": 6.021,
      "roll_deg": 0.248,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo14/AS14-64-9200.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -1063.18,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0691,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0471,
      "n_points": 808,
      "n_outliers": 153,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 9.59,
       "min": 2.72,
       "max": 13.15
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [],
      "batch_photographer_role": "CDR",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS14-64-9200.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo14",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       -19.4,
       -18.7
      ],
      "ground_check_m": 0.04,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    }
   ],
   "quotes": [
    {
     "id": "q-apollo14-5",
     "kind": "quote",
     "person": "A. Shepard",
     "person_full": "Alan B. Shepard Jr.",
     "role": "CDR",
     "mission": "Apollo 14",
     "text": "… Al is on the surface. And it's been a long way, but we're here.",
     "get": "113:51:26",
     "utc": "1971-02-05T14:54:28Z",
     "context": "The first step at Fra Mauro",
     "tag": "Historic quote",
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a14/a14-prelim1.html",
     "source_label": "Apollo 14 Lunar Surface Journal: Down the Ladder for EVA-1",
     "verified": "2026-11-17, word for word against the ALSJ transcript"
    },
    {
     "id": "q-apollo14-6",
     "kind": "quote",
     "person": "A. Shepard",
     "person_full": "Alan B. Shepard Jr.",
     "role": "CDR",
     "mission": "Apollo 14",
     "text": "Miles and miles and miles.",
     "get": "135:09:20",
     "utc": "1971-02-06T12:12:22Z",
     "context": "His second golf shot, at the end of EVA-2",
     "tag": "Historic quote",
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a14/a14.clsout2.html",
     "source_label": "Apollo 14 Lunar Surface Journal: A Nice Day for a Game of Golf",
     "verified": "2026-11-17, word for word against the ALSJ transcript"
    }
   ]
  },
  "apollo15": {
   "name": "Apollo 15 (Hadley-Apennine)",
   "mission": "Apollo 15",
   "photos": [
    {
     "id": "AS15-86-11603",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo15/AS15-86-11603.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo15/AS15-86-11603_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 330429,
     "film": "colour",
     "title": "Irwin at the Rover, Mount Hadley",
     "caption": "Jim Irwin and the Rover at the end of EVA-1; Mount Hadley, 20 km away, behind.",
     "uploader": "D. Scott",
     "uploader_full": "David R. Scott",
     "role": "CDR",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'This excellent picture is the last one that Dave took at the end of EVA-1.'",
     "mission": "Apollo 15",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1971-07-31T19:19:12Z",
     "time_source": "ALSJ image library, mission clock 125:45:12",
     "get": "125:45:12",
     "get_utc": "1971-07-31T19:19:12Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": 26.1322,
      "lon_deg": 3.6339,
      "acc_m": 30,
      "source": "catalog site apollo15 (the LM; the fit used the catalog horizon)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a15/images15.html#11603",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 15 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://images.nasa.gov/details/as15-86-11603",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 46.712,
      "pitch_deg": -7.772,
      "roll_deg": 3.026,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 2.0,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "../horizons/apollo15.json",
      "format": "C3 JSON (catalog site)",
      "observer_height_m": 2.0
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.058,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.007,
      "n_points": 399,
      "n_outliers": 32,
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "without the 32 points on the Rover's antenna"
      ],
      "record": "docs/validation/real_photos.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo15",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       0.0,
       0.0
      ],
      "ground_check_m": 0.0,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS15-92-12448",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo15/AS15-92-12448.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo15/AS15-92-12448_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 401090,
     "film": "black and white",
     "title": "Scott at the flag",
     "caption": "Dave Scott at the flag at the end of EVA-2, the LM behind.",
     "uploader": "J. Irwin",
     "uploader_full": "James B. Irwin",
     "role": "LMP",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Jim took this picture of Dave at the flag at the end of EVA-2.'",
     "mission": "Apollo 15",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1971-08-01T18:30:09Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "148:56:32",
     "get_utc": "1971-08-01T18:30:32Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": 26.132734,
      "lon_deg": 3.633671,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC track"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a15/images15.html#12448",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 15 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://eol.jsc.nasa.gov/DatabaseImages/ISD/highres/AS15/AS15-92-12448.JPG",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 159.192,
      "pitch_deg": -10.582,
      "roll_deg": 3.459,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo15/AS15-92-12448.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -1928.57,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0122,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0081,
      "n_points": 626,
      "n_outliers": 0,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 18.61,
       "min": 14.1,
       "max": 26.34
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [],
      "batch_photographer_role": "LMP",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS15-92-12448.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo15",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       -6.2,
       16.2
      ],
      "ground_check_m": 0.22,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS15-87-11847",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo15/AS15-87-11847.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo15/AS15-87-11847_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 322920,
     "film": "colour",
     "title": "The ALSEP and Scott with the drill",
     "caption": "Dave Scott picks up the drill at the ALSEP; the Solar Wind Spectrometer in the foreground.",
     "uploader": "J. Irwin",
     "uploader_full": "James B. Irwin",
     "role": "LMP",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Jim's ALSEP pan. Dave is leaning to his right and is picking up the drill.'",
     "mission": "Apollo 15",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1971-08-01T17:12:26Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "147:37:42",
     "get_utc": "1971-08-01T17:11:42Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": 26.133684,
      "lon_deg": 3.630608,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC Temporal Traverse: photographer's LROC-located track at the frame times (median)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a15/images15.html#11847",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 15 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://eol.jsc.nasa.gov/DatabaseImages/ISD/highres/AS15/AS15-87-11847.JPG",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 3.56,
      "pitch_deg": -10.309,
      "roll_deg": 5.711,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo15/AS15-87-11847.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -1924.35,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0351,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0148,
      "n_points": 861,
      "n_outliers": 77,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 17.59,
       "min": 0.3,
       "max": 43.29
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [],
      "batch_photographer_role": "LMP",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS15-87-11847.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo15",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       -89.5,
       45.0
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.05,
      "near_share": 0.07,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS15-82-11088",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo15/AS15-82-11088.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo15/AS15-82-11088_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 415292,
     "film": "black and white",
     "title": "Station 9: a fresh crater",
     "caption": "Blocky ejecta around a fresh 15 m crater: soil pressed into rock by the impact.",
     "uploader": "D. Scott",
     "uploader_full": "David R. Scott",
     "role": "CDR",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Dave begins a pan at Station 9' (11066); 11088 is a later frame of that pan.",
     "mission": "Apollo 15",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1971-08-02T10:40:33Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "165:05:09",
     "get_utc": "1971-08-02T10:39:09Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": 26.131036,
      "lon_deg": 3.57254,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC Temporal Traverse: photographer's LROC-located track at the frame times (median)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a15/images15.html#11088",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 15 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://eol.jsc.nasa.gov/DatabaseImages/ISD/highres/AS15/AS15-82-11088.JPG",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 206.176,
      "pitch_deg": -8.186,
      "roll_deg": 0.177,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo15/AS15-82-11088.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -1898.71,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0154,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0098,
      "n_points": 999,
      "n_outliers": 0,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 12.85,
       "min": 9.0,
       "max": 26.12
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [],
      "batch_photographer_role": "CDR",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS15-82-11088.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo15",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       -1668.6,
       -34.9
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.63,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS15-82-11121",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo15/AS15-82-11121.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo15/AS15-82-11121_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 335605,
     "film": "black and white",
     "title": "Hadley Rille",
     "caption": "The view south along Hadley Rille, with Dave Scott at the Rover.",
     "uploader": "J. Irwin",
     "uploader_full": "James B. Irwin",
     "role": "LMP",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'This frame from Jim's Station 9a pan shows the view south along Hadley Rille.'",
     "mission": "Apollo 15",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1971-08-02T10:56:34Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "165:21:14",
     "get_utc": "1971-08-02T10:55:14Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": 26.13096,
      "lon_deg": 3.563974,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC Temporal Traverse: photographer's LROC-located track at the frame times (median)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a15/images15.html#11121",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 15 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://eol.jsc.nasa.gov/DatabaseImages/ISD/highres/AS15/AS15-82-11121.JPG",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 160.568,
      "pitch_deg": -8.732,
      "roll_deg": 4.114,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo15/AS15-82-11121.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -1906.97,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0137,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0082,
      "n_points": 915,
      "n_outliers": 0,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 12.85,
       "min": 9.18,
       "max": 21.08
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [],
      "batch_photographer_role": "LMP",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS15-82-11121.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo15",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       -1901.6,
       -37.0
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.8,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS15-88-11903",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo15/AS15-88-11903.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo15/AS15-88-11903_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 237668,
     "film": "colour",
     "title": "Memorial and Mount Hadley",
     "caption": "From the Rover's last parking place: the astronaut and cosmonaut memorial, and Mount Hadley.",
     "uploader": "D. Scott",
     "uploader_full": "David R. Scott",
     "role": "CDR",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Dave has started a pan from the VIP site' (11895); 11903 shows the memorial.",
     "mission": "Apollo 15",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1971-08-02T13:23:23Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "167:48:59",
     "get_utc": "1971-08-02T13:22:59Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": 26.131642,
      "lon_deg": 3.637961,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC Temporal Traverse: photographer's LROC-located track at the frame times (median)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a15/images15.html#11903",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 15 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://eol.jsc.nasa.gov/DatabaseImages/ISD/highres/AS15/AS15-88-11903.JPG",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 25.76,
      "pitch_deg": -8.761,
      "roll_deg": 3.361,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo15/AS15-88-11903.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -1927.0,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0259,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0129,
      "n_points": 974,
      "n_outliers": 0,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 18.89,
       "min": 17.35,
       "max": 43.29
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "heading weakly fixed (another heading fits almost as well)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "CDR",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS15-88-11903.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo15",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       110.4,
       -16.9
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.74,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    }
   ],
   "quotes": [
    {
     "id": "q-apollo15-7",
     "kind": "quote",
     "person": "D. Scott",
     "person_full": "David R. Scott",
     "role": "CDR",
     "mission": "Apollo 15",
     "text": "Okay, Houston. As I stand out here in the wonders of the unknown at Hadley, I sort of realize there's a fundamental truth to our nature. Man must explore. And this is exploration at its greatest.",
     "get": "119:55:45",
     "utc": "1971-07-31T13:29:45Z",
     "context": "First words on the surface at Hadley",
     "tag": "Historic quote",
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a15/a15.lrvdep.html",
     "source_label": "Apollo 15 Lunar Surface Journal: Deploying the Lunar Roving Vehicle",
     "verified": "2026-11-17, word for word against the ALSJ transcript"
    },
    {
     "id": "q-apollo15-8",
     "kind": "quote",
     "person": "J. Irwin",
     "person_full": "James B. Irwin",
     "role": "LMP",
     "mission": "Apollo 15",
     "text": "Oh, boy. It's beautiful out here! Reminds me of Sun Valley.",
     "get": "120:03:49",
     "utc": "1971-07-31T13:37:49Z",
     "context": "Just after stepping onto the surface",
     "tag": "Historic quote",
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a15/a15.lrvdep.html",
     "source_label": "Apollo 15 Lunar Surface Journal: Deploying the Lunar Roving Vehicle",
     "verified": "2026-11-17, word for word against the ALSJ transcript"
    }
   ]
  },
  "apollo16": {
   "name": "Apollo 16 (Descartes Highlands)",
   "mission": "Apollo 16",
   "photos": [
    {
     "id": "AS16-109-17789",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo16/AS16-109-17789.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo16/AS16-109-17789_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 399986,
     "film": "black and white",
     "title": "Plum Crater and the Rover",
     "caption": "John Young comes over from the Rover at Station 1; Plum Crater on the right, Stone Mountain behind.",
     "uploader": "C. Duke",
     "uploader_full": "Charles M. Duke Jr.",
     "role": "LMP",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Charlie's first Station 1 pan ... John has left the Rover and is coming over to join Charlie.'",
     "mission": "Apollo 16",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1972-04-21T21:18:58Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "123:25:08",
     "get_utc": "1972-04-21T21:19:08Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": -8.975648,
      "lon_deg": 15.452266,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC Temporal Traverse: photographer's LROC-located track at the frame times (median)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a16/images16.html#17789",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 16 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a16/AS16-109-17789HR.jpg",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 171.378,
      "pitch_deg": -6.694,
      "roll_deg": 2.814,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo16/AS16-109-17789.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": 1.32,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0199,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0136,
      "n_points": 1170,
      "n_outliers": 0,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 8.14,
       "min": 6.1,
       "max": 30.03
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "heading weakly fixed (another heading fits almost as well)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "LMP",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS16-109-17789.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo16",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       -1435.7,
       -80.4
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.8,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS16-114-18427",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo16/AS16-114-18427.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo16/AS16-114-18427_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 347977,
     "film": "colour",
     "title": "Duke at Plum Crater",
     "caption": "Charlie Duke walks south to look at angular blocks; Stone Mountain in the background.",
     "uploader": "J. Young",
     "uploader_full": "John W. Young",
     "role": "CDR",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'This frame from John Young's Plum Crater pan shows Charlie as he moves to the south'.",
     "mission": "Apollo 16",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1972-04-21T21:56:34Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "124:02:22",
     "get_utc": "1972-04-21T21:56:22Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": -8.97678,
      "lon_deg": 15.451308,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC Temporal Traverse: photographer's LROC-located track at the frame times (median)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a16/images16.html#18427",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 16 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://eol.jsc.nasa.gov/DatabaseImages/ISD/highres/AS16/AS16-114-18427.JPG",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 153.05,
      "pitch_deg": -7.96,
      "roll_deg": 0.75,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo16/AS16-114-18427.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -1.36,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.027,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.017,
      "n_points": 976,
      "n_outliers": 0,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 6.29,
       "min": 5.8,
       "max": 13.62
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [],
      "batch_photographer_role": "CDR",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS16-114-18427.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo16",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       -1464.4,
       -114.7
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.39,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS16-114-18388",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo16/AS16-114-18388.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo16/AS16-114-18388_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 267815,
     "film": "colour",
     "title": "Young at the ALSEP",
     "caption": "John Young uses the top of the camera as a table to fill a sample bag.",
     "uploader": "C. Duke",
     "uploader_full": "Charles M. Duke Jr.",
     "role": "LMP",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'This picture shows John at the ALSEP site'; the magazine was then in Charlie's hands.",
     "mission": "Apollo 16",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1972-04-21T20:40:10Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "122:46:09",
     "get_utc": "1972-04-21T20:40:09Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": -8.976314,
      "lon_deg": 15.498585,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC track"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a16/images16.html#18388",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 16 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://eol.jsc.nasa.gov/DatabaseImages/ISD/highres/AS16/AS16-114-18388.JPG",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 317.39,
      "pitch_deg": -7.805,
      "roll_deg": 4.054,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo16/AS16-114-18388.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": 12.33,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0629,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.034,
      "n_points": 526,
      "n_outliers": 33,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 1.12,
       "min": 0.35,
       "max": 1.72
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "heading weakly fixed (another heading fits almost as well)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "LMP",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS16-114-18388.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo16",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       -48.4,
       -100.5
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.43,
      "near_share": 0.41,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     },
     "limit": {
      "kind": "near_horizon",
      "near_share": 0.41,
      "short": "Recreation limited: near horizon < 1 km",
      "text": "Recreation limited: over 41 % of this frame the skyline is nearer than 1 km, where the elevation data (59 m cells) cannot draw the real crater rims and rises. The far skyline is exact; the near one is not."
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS16-107-17433",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo16/AS16-107-17433.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo16/AS16-107-17433_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 263880,
     "film": "colour",
     "title": "The LM at the start of EVA-2",
     "caption": "The east leg of the lunar module, from Duke's pan at the start of EVA-2.",
     "uploader": "C. Duke",
     "uploader_full": "Charles M. Duke Jr.",
     "role": "LMP",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Frames 17419-40 taken by Charlie Duke at the LM early in EVA-2.'",
     "mission": "Apollo 16",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1972-04-22T17:07:32Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": null,
     "get_utc": null,
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": -8.972964,
      "lon_deg": 15.50115,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC Temporal Traverse: photographer's LROC-located track at the frame times (median)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a16/images16.html#17433",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 16 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://eol.jsc.nasa.gov/DatabaseImages/ISD/highres/AS16/AS16-107-17433.JPG",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 159.09,
      "pitch_deg": -2.878,
      "roll_deg": -0.571,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo16/AS16-107-17433.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": 12.19,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0333,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0164,
      "n_points": 816,
      "n_outliers": 159,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 5.66,
       "min": 5.15,
       "max": 6.1
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "broken photo skyline (9 jumps: unlit or low-contrast slope)",
       "heading weakly fixed (another heading fits almost as well)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "LMP",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS16-107-17433.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo16",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       28.5,
       1.1
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.21,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS16-108-17670",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo16/AS16-108-17670.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo16/AS16-108-17670_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 340184,
     "film": "black and white",
     "title": "Aligning the antenna",
     "caption": "John Young aims the Rover's high-gain antenna at the Earth at Station 8.",
     "uploader": "C. Duke",
     "uploader_full": "Charles M. Duke Jr.",
     "role": "LMP",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Charlie's Station 8 pan ... showing John aligning the high gain antenna.'",
     "mission": "Apollo 16",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1972-04-22T20:37:58Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "146:43:51",
     "get_utc": "1972-04-22T20:37:51Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": -9.064679,
      "lon_deg": 15.477647,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC Temporal Traverse: photographer's LROC-located track at the frame times (median)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a16/images16.html#17670",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 16 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a16/AS16-108-17670HR.jpg",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 45.88,
      "pitch_deg": -6.827,
      "roll_deg": 4.114,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo16/AS16-108-17670.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": 2.97,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0471,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0102,
      "n_points": 948,
      "n_outliers": 218,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 16.64,
       "min": 2.72,
       "max": 25.39
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "broken photo skyline (8 jumps: unlit or low-contrast slope)",
       "heading weakly fixed (another heading fits almost as well)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "LMP",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS16-108-17670.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo16",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       -675.3,
       -2780.0
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.32,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS16-108-17730",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo16/AS16-108-17730.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo16/AS16-108-17730_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 341392,
     "film": "black and white",
     "title": "Station 9",
     "caption": "John Young with the dust brush at the front of the Rover.",
     "uploader": "C. Duke",
     "uploader_full": "Charles M. Duke Jr.",
     "role": "LMP",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Charlie's Station 9 pan ... showing John with the dustbrush at the front of the Rover'.",
     "mission": "Apollo 16",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1972-04-22T21:51:01Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "147:56:45",
     "get_utc": "1972-04-22T21:50:45Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": -9.053298,
      "lon_deg": 15.483939,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC Temporal Traverse: photographer's LROC-located track at the frame times (median)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a16/images16.html#17730",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 16 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a16/AS16-108-17730HR.jpg",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 108.89,
      "pitch_deg": -2.575,
      "roll_deg": 0.717,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo16/AS16-108-17730.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -7.84,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0378,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.019,
      "n_points": 1115,
      "n_outliers": 32,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 2.72,
       "min": 1.54,
       "max": 3.91
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "broken photo skyline (13 jumps: unlit or low-contrast slope)",
       "heading weakly fixed (another heading fits almost as well)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "LMP",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS16-108-17730.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo16",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       -486.9,
       -2434.9
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.13,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    }
   ],
   "quotes": [
    {
     "id": "q-apollo16-9",
     "kind": "quote",
     "person": "J. Young",
     "person_full": "John W. Young",
     "role": "CDR",
     "mission": "Apollo 16",
     "text": "There you are: Mysterious and Unknown Descartes. Highland plains. Apollo 16 is gonna change your image.",
     "get": "119:04:05",
     "utc": "1972-04-21T16:58:05Z",
     "context": "Stepping off the footpad",
     "tag": "Historic quote",
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a16/a16.eva1prelim.html",
     "source_label": "Apollo 16 Lunar Surface Journal: Back in the Briar Patch",
     "verified": "2026-11-17, word for word against the ALSJ transcript"
    },
    {
     "id": "q-apollo16-10",
     "kind": "quote",
     "person": "C. Duke",
     "person_full": "Charles M. Duke Jr.",
     "role": "LMP",
     "mission": "Apollo 16",
     "text": "Fantastic! Oh, that first foot on the lunar surface is super, Tony!",
     "get": "119:06:24",
     "utc": "1972-04-21T17:00:24Z",
     "context": "Stepping off the LM",
     "tag": "Historic quote",
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a16/a16.eva1prelim.html",
     "source_label": "Apollo 16 Lunar Surface Journal: Back in the Briar Patch",
     "verified": "2026-11-17, word for word against the ALSJ transcript"
    }
   ]
  },
  "apollo17": {
   "name": "Apollo 17 (Taurus-Littrow)",
   "mission": "Apollo 17",
   "photos": [
    {
     "id": "AS17-137-20873",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo17/AS17-137-20873.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo17/AS17-137-20873_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 255834,
     "film": "colour",
     "title": "The LM and the North Massif",
     "caption": "From the LM pan at the start of EVA-2, looking north-north-west.",
     "uploader": "H. Schmitt",
     "uploader_full": "Harrison H. Schmitt",
     "role": "LMP",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Jack's LM pan taken at the start of EVA-2 with Gene's camera'.",
     "mission": "Apollo 17",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1972-12-12T23:53:16Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "141:01:23",
     "get_utc": "1972-12-12T23:54:23Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": 20.1903,
      "lon_deg": 30.77184,
      "acc_m": 3.0,
      "source": "real_photos.md section 3: the LM of Haase et al. (2019) plus 19 m toward azimuth 166 deg, measured on AS17-137-20873 (the LROC track is 19 m away)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a17/images17.html#20873",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 17 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://eol.jsc.nasa.gov/DatabaseImages/ISD/highres/AS17/AS17-137-20873.JPG",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 340.216,
      "pitch_deg": -4.145,
      "roll_deg": 1.434,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo17/AS17-137-20873.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -2627.87,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0222,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0144,
      "n_points": 626,
      "n_outliers": 138,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 7.05,
       "min": 6.28,
       "max": 10.3
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "broken photo skyline (11 jumps: unlit or low-contrast slope)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "LMP",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS17-137-20873.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo17",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       4.0,
       -15.1
      ],
      "ground_check_m": 0.29,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS17-137-20958",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo17/AS17-137-20958.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo17/AS17-137-20958_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 118532,
     "film": "colour",
     "title": "The Earth over the South Massif",
     "caption": "From Station 2: the Earth, 44.5 degrees high, above the South Massif.",
     "uploader": "E. Cernan",
     "uploader_full": "Eugene A. Cernan",
     "role": "CDR",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'After finishing the pan, Gene turns and takes three photos of the Earth over the South Massif'.",
     "mission": "Apollo 17",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1972-12-13T02:17:53Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "143:23:22",
     "get_utc": "1972-12-13T02:16:22Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": 20.09807,
      "lon_deg": 30.528699,
      "acc_m": 10.0,
      "source": "Haase et al. (2019) 'Station 2, Southwest pan'"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a17/images17.html#20958",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 17 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://eol.jsc.nasa.gov/DatabaseImages/ISD/highres/AS17/AS17-137-20958.JPG",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 240.64,
      "pitch_deg": 42.152,
      "roll_deg": 5.531,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo17/AS17-137-20958.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -2432.63,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0441,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0318,
      "n_points": 976,
      "n_outliers": 0,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 3.14,
       "min": 2.25,
       "max": 3.79
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [],
      "batch_photographer_role": "CDR",
      "earth": {
       "moonat_az_deg": 239.486,
       "moonat_el_deg": 44.52,
       "found": true,
       "photo_az_deg": 238.538,
       "photo_el_deg": 44.664,
       "d_el_deg": 0.143,
       "d_az_deg": -0.948,
       "d_cross_deg": -0.676,
       "separation_deg": 0.69,
       "limb_points": 178,
       "limb_rms_px": 0.34
      },
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS17-137-20958.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo17",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       -6910.2,
       -2802.9
      ],
      "ground_check_m": 0.63,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS17-140-21497",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo17/AS17-140-21497.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo17/AS17-140-21497_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 261615,
     "film": "colour",
     "title": "Tracy's Rock",
     "caption": "Jack Schmitt at the split boulder of Station 6; the East Massif and Bear Mountain behind.",
     "uploader": "E. Cernan",
     "uploader_full": "Eugene A. Cernan",
     "role": "CDR",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Station 6 pan (north). Jack, Tracy's Rock' (Jack is in the frame, so Gene took it).",
     "mission": "Apollo 17",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1972-12-14T00:27:29Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": null,
     "get_utc": null,
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": 20.2908,
      "lon_deg": 30.800513,
      "acc_m": 10.0,
      "source": "Haase et al. (2019) control point 'Station 6, North pan' (11 m from the LROC track)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a17/images17.html#21497",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 17 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://eol.jsc.nasa.gov/DatabaseImages/ISD/highres/AS17/AS17-140-21497.JPG",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 171.668,
      "pitch_deg": -5.77,
      "roll_deg": -0.403,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo17/AS17-140-21497.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -2562.48,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0331,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0155,
      "n_points": 971,
      "n_outliers": 5,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 24.94,
       "min": 18.42,
       "max": 41.4
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "heading weakly fixed (another heading fits almost as well)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "CDR",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS17-140-21497.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo17",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       818.3,
       3027.9
      ],
      "ground_check_m": 0.07,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS17-134-20439",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo17/AS17-134-20439.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo17/AS17-134-20439_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 273631,
     "film": "colour",
     "title": "Deploying the SEP",
     "caption": "Jack Schmitt sets up the transmitter of the Surface Electrical Properties experiment.",
     "uploader": "E. Cernan",
     "uploader_full": "Eugene A. Cernan",
     "role": "CDR",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'This frame from Gene's SEP partial pan shows Jack as he deploys the SEP transmitter.'",
     "mission": "Apollo 17",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1972-12-12T05:59:34Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "123:06:24",
     "get_utc": "1972-12-12T05:59:24Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": 20.192211,
      "lon_deg": 30.776661,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC Temporal Traverse: photographer's LROC-located track at the frame times (median)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a17/images17.html#20439",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 17 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://eol.jsc.nasa.gov/DatabaseImages/ISD/highres/AS17/AS17-134-20439.JPG",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 230.002,
      "pitch_deg": -8.567,
      "roll_deg": 1.731,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo17/AS17-134-20439.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -2629.25,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0182,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0111,
      "n_points": 975,
      "n_outliers": 0,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 11.85,
       "min": 11.19,
       "max": 12.56
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [],
      "batch_photographer_role": "CDR",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS17-134-20439.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo17",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       141.0,
       42.7
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.79,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS17-147-22527",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo17/AS17-147-22527.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo17/AS17-147-22527_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 214432,
     "film": "colour",
     "title": "The Rover's test drive",
     "caption": "Gene Cernan drives the Rover between Jack and the LM on its first test drive.",
     "uploader": "H. Schmitt",
     "uploader_full": "Harrison H. Schmitt",
     "role": "LMP",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Gene passing between Jack and the LM during the initial test drive'; magazine used by Jack.",
     "mission": "Apollo 17",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1972-12-12T00:42:23Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": "117:48:26",
     "get_utc": "1972-12-12T00:41:26Z",
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": 20.191352,
      "lon_deg": 30.772386,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC Temporal Traverse: photographer's LROC-located track at the frame times (median)"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a17/images17.html#22527",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 17 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://eol.jsc.nasa.gov/DatabaseImages/ISD/highres/AS17/AS17-147-22527.JPG",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 242.448,
      "pitch_deg": 10.301,
      "roll_deg": -1.699,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo17/AS17-147-22527.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -2627.84,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0308,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0093,
      "n_points": 927,
      "n_outliers": 51,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 11.79,
       "min": 11.07,
       "max": 12.43
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "broken photo skyline (15 jumps: unlit or low-contrast slope)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "LMP",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS17-147-22527.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo17",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       19.5,
       16.7
      ],
      "ground_check_m": 0.41,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS17-140-21387",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo17/AS17-140-21387.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo17/AS17-140-21387_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 242513,
     "film": "colour",
     "title": "Schmitt at the flag",
     "caption": "Jack Schmitt at the flag at the start of EVA-3, the camera on his chest.",
     "uploader": "E. Cernan",
     "uploader_full": "Eugene A. Cernan",
     "role": "CDR",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'Gene Cernan uses the magazine to take three tourist pictures of Jack at the LM' (21385-21387); 21387: 'Similar to 21385 and 21386'.",
     "mission": "Apollo 17",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1972-12-13T23:04:12Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": null,
     "get_utc": null,
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": 20.191657,
      "lon_deg": 30.771872,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC track"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a17/images17.html#21387",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 17 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://eol.jsc.nasa.gov/DatabaseImages/ISD/highres/AS17/AS17-140-21387.JPG",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 36.136,
      "pitch_deg": 0.364,
      "roll_deg": -2.611,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo17/AS17-140-21387.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -2626.97,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0352,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0185,
      "n_points": 978,
      "n_outliers": 0,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 7.82,
       "min": 6.93,
       "max": 11.85
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "heading weakly fixed (another heading fits almost as well)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "CDR",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS17-140-21387.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo17",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       4.9,
       25.9
      ],
      "ground_check_m": 0.05,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "AS17-143-21932",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "apollo17/AS17-143-21932.jpg",
     "thumb": "apollo17/AS17-143-21932_t.jpg",
     "width": 1600,
     "height": 1600,
     "bytes": 299727,
     "film": "black and white",
     "title": "The Rover's last parking place",
     "caption": "The Rover at the VIP site; Jack Schmitt is walking back from the ALSEP beyond it.",
     "uploader": "E. Cernan",
     "uploader_full": "Eugene A. Cernan",
     "role": "CDR",
     "credit_status": "confirmed",
     "credit_note": "ALSJ: 'This is probably the best of the pictures Gene took of the Rover at its final parking spot'.",
     "mission": "Apollo 17",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1972-12-14T05:13:25Z",
     "time_source": "LROC Temporal Traverse frame time",
     "get": null,
     "get_utc": null,
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": 20.189615,
      "lon_deg": 30.777004,
      "acc_m": 30.0,
      "source": "LROC track"
     },
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a17/images17.html#21932",
     "source_label": "ALSJ Apollo 17 Image Library",
     "scan_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a17/AS17-143-21932HR.jpg",
     "camera": {
      "model": "hasselblad_61",
      "heading_deg": 304.808,
      "pitch_deg": -2.766,
      "roll_deg": 2.562,
      "hfov_deg": 46.894,
      "vfov_deg": 46.894,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre"
     },
     "horizon": {
      "file": "apollo17/AS17-143-21932.hz.bin",
      "format": "int16 el (0.01 deg) then uint16 dist (0.01 km), little-endian",
      "az_step_deg": 0.1,
      "n": 3600,
      "ground_elev_m": -2633.99,
      "observer_height_m": 1.5,
      "dem_sources": [
       "SLDEM2015 LOLA+SELENE TC (512 px/deg, ~59 m; Barker et al. 2016), NASA PDS",
       "LOLA LDEM_64 (64 px/deg, ~474 m), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences",
       "LOLA LDEM_16 (16 px/deg, ~1.9 km), LRO-L-LOLA-4-GDR-V1.0, NASA PDS Geosciences"
      ],
      "bytes": 14400
     },
     "fit": {
      "skyline_rms_deg": 0.0295,
      "skyline_median_abs_deg": 0.0149,
      "n_points": 884,
      "n_outliers": 210,
      "skyline_km": {
       "median": 13.03,
       "min": 0.06,
       "max": 28.78
      },
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [
       "broken photo skyline (16 jumps: unlit or low-contrast slope)",
       "heading weakly fixed (another heading fits almost as well)"
      ],
      "batch_photographer_role": "CDR",
      "earth": null,
      "record": "docs/validation/photo_batch/AS17-143-21932.json"
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "apollo17",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       150.7,
       -35.9
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.12,
      "near_share": 0.14,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    }
   ],
   "quotes": [
    {
     "id": "q-apollo17-11",
     "kind": "quote",
     "person": "H. Schmitt",
     "person_full": "Harrison H. Schmitt",
     "role": "LMP",
     "mission": "Apollo 17",
     "text": "Where are the reflections? I've been fooled once. There is orange soil!!",
     "get": "145:26:27",
     "utc": "1972-12-13T04:19:27Z",
     "context": "Shorty Crater, Station 4",
     "tag": "Historic quote",
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a17/a17.sta4.html",
     "source_label": "Apollo 17 Lunar Surface Journal: Orange Soil on the Moon",
     "verified": "2026-11-17, word for word against the ALSJ transcript"
    },
    {
     "id": "q-apollo17-12",
     "kind": "quote",
     "person": "E. Cernan",
     "person_full": "Eugene A. Cernan",
     "role": "CDR",
     "mission": "Apollo 17",
     "text": "… And, as we leave the Moon at Taurus-Littrow, we leave as we came and, God willing, as we shall return, with peace and hope for all mankind. ‘Godspeed the crew of Apollo 17.’",
     "get": "170:41:00",
     "utc": "1972-12-14T05:34:00Z",
     "context": "The last words on the Moon, before climbing the ladder",
     "tag": "Historic quote",
     "source_url": "https://apollojournals.org/alsj/a17/a17.clsout3.html",
     "source_label": "Apollo 17 Lunar Surface Journal: EVA-3 Close-out",
     "verified": "2026-11-17, word for word against the ALSJ transcript"
    }
   ]
  },
  "surveyor3": {
   "name": "Surveyor 3",
   "mission": "Surveyor 3",
   "photos": [
    {
     "id": "SP-146-Fig-3-43b",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "surveyor3/SP-146-Fig-3-43b.jpg",
     "thumb": "surveyor3/SP-146-Fig-3-43b_t.jpg",
     "width": 330,
     "height": 330,
     "bytes": 16257,
     "film": "television (vidicon), green filter",
     "frame_label": "NASA SP-146 Fig. 3-43 (b)",
     "title": "The Earth eclipses the Sun",
     "caption": "Sunlight bent through the Earth's atmosphere rings the night side of the Earth (green filter).",
     "uploader": "Surveyor 3 · NASA",
     "uploader_full": "Surveyor 3 television camera (NASA / JPL)",
     "role": "lander",
     "credit_status": "mission",
     "credit_note": "NASA SP-146, Surveyor III: A Preliminary Report (1967), television observations, pp. 50-58.",
     "mission": "Surveyor 3",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1967-04-24T11:23:06Z",
     "time_source": "NASA SP-146 figure caption (GMT)",
     "get": null,
     "get_utc": null,
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": -3.015,
      "lon_deg": -23.418,
      "acc_m": 30,
      "source": "catalog site surveyor3"
     },
     "source_url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/19670023253",
     "source_label": "NASA SP-146 (NTRS 19670023253)",
     "scan_url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/19670023253/downloads/19670023253.pdf",
     "camera": {
      "model": "surveyor_tv",
      "heading_deg": 84.541,
      "pitch_deg": 64.979,
      "roll_deg": -75.15,
      "hfov_deg": 3.511,
      "vfov_deg": 3.511,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre",
      "aim": "earth",
      "note": "Pointing not recorded: the view is centred on the Earth; field of view from the Earth's size, roll from the lit side of the Earth."
     },
     "horizon": null,
     "fit": {
      "match_text": "Sun's centre behind the Earth within 0.05 deg of NASA's 1967 drawing (SP-146 Fig. 3-40)",
      "match_deg": 0.047,
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [],
      "record": "docs/validation/real_photos.md section 6",
      "earth_radius_px": 96.3
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "surveyor3",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       0.0,
       0.0
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.0,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    },
    {
     "id": "SP-146-Fig-3-46b",
     "kind": "photo",
     "image": "surveyor3/SP-146-Fig-3-46b.jpg",
     "thumb": "surveyor3/SP-146-Fig-3-46b_t.jpg",
     "width": 290,
     "height": 290,
     "bytes": 5282,
     "film": "television (vidicon), green filter",
     "frame_label": "NASA SP-146 Fig. 3-46 (b)",
     "title": "A crescent Earth",
     "caption": "The Earth from Surveyor 3, six days after the eclipse (green filter).",
     "uploader": "Surveyor 3 · NASA",
     "uploader_full": "Surveyor 3 television camera (NASA / JPL)",
     "role": "lander",
     "credit_status": "mission",
     "credit_note": "NASA SP-146, Surveyor III: A Preliminary Report (1967), television observations, pp. 50-58.",
     "mission": "Surveyor 3",
     "agency": "NASA",
     "licence": "public domain (NASA)",
     "tag": "Historic photo · NASA",
     "taken_utc": "1967-04-30T10:37:18Z",
     "time_source": "NASA SP-146 figure caption (GMT)",
     "get": null,
     "get_utc": null,
     "place": {
      "lat_deg": -3.015,
      "lon_deg": -23.418,
      "acc_m": 30,
      "source": "catalog site surveyor3"
     },
     "source_url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/19670023253",
     "source_label": "NASA SP-146 (NTRS 19670023253)",
     "scan_url": "https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/19670023253/downloads/19670023253.pdf",
     "camera": {
      "model": "surveyor_tv",
      "heading_deg": 72.167,
      "pitch_deg": 57.798,
      "roll_deg": -82.7,
      "hfov_deg": 2.919,
      "vfov_deg": 2.919,
      "eye_m": 1.5,
      "principal_point": "image centre",
      "aim": "earth",
      "note": "Pointing not recorded: the view is centred on the Earth; field of view from the Earth's size, roll from the lit side of the Earth."
     },
     "horizon": null,
     "fit": {
      "match_text": "Lit share: Moonat 0.40; the TV picture 0.34-0.35 (a threshold measures a crescent small)",
      "match_deg": null,
      "verdict": "good",
      "flags": [],
      "record": "docs/validation/real_photos.md section 6",
      "earth_radius_px": 94.0
     },
     "recreation": "live",
     "terrain": {
      "patch": "surveyor3",
      "dem": "SLDEM2015 59 m (the catalog site's C4 patch, +-12 km) and its far rings to 91 km (SLDEM2015, LDEM_64), moved to the camera place: the DEMs of the fit's horizon profile",
      "offset_m": [
       0.0,
       0.0
      ],
      "ground_check_m": -0.0,
      "near_share": 0.0,
      "decoration": "none (no procedural rocks or micro relief)"
     }
    }
   ],
   "quotes": []
  },
  "starhab": {
   "name": "StarHab (home base)",
   "mission": null,
   "photos": [],
   "quotes": [],
   "disclaimer": "A public post, quoted as written; not an endorsement of Moonat.",
   "posts": [
    {
     "id": "x-starhab-0",
     "kind": "post",
     "tag": "Public post",
     "person": "E. Musk",
     "person_full": "Elon Musk",
     "text": "This will be so awesome 🤩",
     "emoji_exception": "Shay, 2026-11-19: the post's closing emoji (U+1F929, star-struck face) is kept, as posted; the one exception to Moonat's no-emoji rule",
     "utc": "2026-02-09T20:46:54Z",
     "time_source": "the X status id (its timestamp: id >> 22, plus 1288834974657 ms)",
     "context": "On the International Space University proposal to turn a Starship into a lunar base",
     "platform": "X",
     "source_url": "https://x.com/elonmusk/status/2020962635156684920",
     "source_label": "Elon Musk on X, 9 Feb 2026",
     "quoted_post_url": "https://x.com/tobyliiiiiiiiii/status/2020920950297067784",
     "found_via": "https://davidson.org.il/read-experience/en/science-news-en/monat-on-the-moon/",
     "credit": "StarHab concept: Shay Monat and the ISU SSP21 team (IAC 2021)",
     "verified": "2026-11-19: the link and the words, with the closing emoji, from the Davidson Institute article that embeds the post; the id's timestamp (20:46 UTC) is after the quoted post's (18:01 UTC, 9 Feb 2026)"
    }
   ]
  }
 }
}
